The purpose of this blog is to state my
position in managerial strategies to overcome organizational challenges or
external threats. My position is that
managers should stay alert to stakeholder engagement. I will explain the process to stakeholder
engagement by focusing on the gaps and missed opportunities.
Businesses succeed when stakeholder engagement is at its
optimum (Strand, 2008). Moreover, companies that do not measure
stakeholder engagement fail to manage productivity. Systematic measurement of stakeholder
involvement is essential to oversee organizational productivity.
Modern organizations require more than ever stakeholder
engagement for sustainability (Strand, 2008).
The implementation of the service
industry is much different from a mechanical organization. Organic self-actualizing organic structures calls
for the innovative processes of socialization.
Without stakeholder engagement, socialization, productivity, and
commitment do not take place.
For example, J. C. Penney
Company, Inc., commonly known as JCPenney, has a combination of mechanical and
organic management structure. The pre-existing
CEO introduced change by restructuring department processes, implementing
marketing strategies not in alignment with stakeholder needs, and focuses in
hiring people not qualified in correcting the problems to stakeholder engagement
(Murray, 2013a, 2013b). The missed opportunity for JCPenney lies
heavily within the horizontal primary activities. Moreover, JCPenney Marketing and Sales
strategy are no longer valid.
Consequently, JCPenney failed in examining value chain process and presented
improper value chain diagnosis. Buying
practices have changed for most consumers in pursuing more value and lower
prices. Lastly, JCPenney introduces all
the challenges required to perform a sustainable solutions study from the
weaknesses revealed.
Managers have a large responsibility to motivate employees that
way employees perform tasks (Strand, 2008). Managers acting in behalf of the organization
must realize a form to understand an employee’s role within communities and
assist in making a fit to the organization.
The organization must offer stakeholder a balance between organizational
culture, compensation, and task for long-term sustainability.
Stakeholder perceptions should quantify for measuring the
goals of the organization (Strand, 2008). Stakeholder dashboard is a utility of
measurement of stakeholder perceptions. Managers
use the stakeholder dashboard to make an analysis of stakeholder’s
organizational fit, and compare the measurements to organizational performance
indicators.
Organizations should identify stakeholders that do not affect
the organization directly or stakeholders that represent a minimum loss
indirectly (Strand, 2008). Caution is necessary in attempting to gather
stakeholder information. Organizations
making inquiries to stakeholder preferences will need the expertise of consultants
to avoid internal conflict. The
information needed from stakeholders gathers from a gap analysis.
A gap analysis is an essential tool through the decision
making process. The decision making process
requires thinking to derive a decision (Harrison, 1996). The stages
to decision making include finding occasions for making a decision, ruling possible
courses of action, and selecting courses of action. The decision can arrive by the placement of
events, the scenery of activities, or the interaction among stakeholders. In essence, it resembles an opportunity that
arrives when circumstances allow.
The decision making process in organizations depicts
scenarios of missing gaps (Harrison, 1996). The gaps
affiliate typically with the needs of the organization. The gap between the external environment and
the stature of the organization is the strategic gap. In other words, the organization considers
its strategic position to the desired strategic position.
A consultant can find the missing gaps and implement a
medium to find the gaps (Strand, 2008). The stakeholder group can consist of
employees, customers, shareholders, suppliers, Wall Street analysts, community,
media, regulators, bond rates, universities, environment, and NGOs. The stakeholders groups vary by the
characteristics of the organization. Table 1 below represents examples of the
methods for stakeholder assessment with public organizations.
Table 1. Stakeholder Assessment
Stakeholder
|
Methods of Perception Assessment
|
Common Source
|
Likelihood of Availability?
|
Employees
|
Surveys, Attrition Rates
|
Human Resources
|
Medium
|
Customers
|
Customer satisfaction surveys
|
Sales, marketing
|
Medium
|
Shareholders
|
Stock Price
|
finance.yahoo.com, investor
relations
|
High
|
Suppliers
|
Surveys, internal assessment
|
Supply chain
|
Low
|
Wall Street Analysts
|
Buy/sell/hold ratings
|
finance.yahoo.com, investor
relations
|
High
|
Community
|
Surveys, internal assessment
|
Public relations, foundation
|
Low
|
Media
|
Negative/positive story
percentages, internal assessment
|
Public relations, communications
|
Low
|
Regulators
|
Internal assessment
|
Compliance
|
Low
|
Bond Raters
|
Bond ratings
|
finance.yahoo.com, investor
relations
|
High
|
Universities
|
Surveys, offer acceptance rates
|
Human Resources
|
Medium
|
Environment
|
Internal assessment
|
Safety, health, environment (SHE)
|
Low
|
NGOs
|
Internal assessment
|
Public relations, communications
|
Low
|
The table above assists managers in finding the missing gaps
between organizations and stakeholders.
Acquiring the information for the gap analysis may represent
a challenge in reservations the organization may have to stakeholders (Strand, 2008).
Compiling the data into stakeholders
groups may miss some of the features reserved by organizations that store information. The data stored in separate organizations
could represent a different set of definitions. The data measures by placing weights of
importance to the information, selecting data reflecting the characteristic of
the organization and measuring by a matter of quantifying and averaging the
data. The last steps to analyzing
stakeholder information include gathering perceptions, reviewing the findings,
and presenting the findings.
Conclusion
To succeed, managers must maintain all pertinent
stakeholders engaged. Stakeholders must
maintain the socialization, goals, and commitments in continuum. The larger the organization is out of touch
from communities. Managers must react by
keeping socialization active to pass on relevant organizational culture
changes. Changes in organizational
culture with stakeholders are quantifiable.
The quantification expresses through gaps in organizational engagement
and store across the stakeholder dashboard.
The differences change to goals and realize, by a decision process, to
achieve cohesion.
References
Harrison, E. F. (1996). A process perspective on
strategic decision making. Management
Decision, 34(1), 46-53. doi: 10.1108/00251749610106972
Murray, L. (2013a, March 7). J.C. Penney lays off
2,200 from stores across the nation. Dallas
Business Journal. Retrieved from
http://www.bizjournals.com/dallas/blog/morning_call/2013/03/jc-penney-lays-off-2200-from-stores.html
Murray, L. (2013b, March 8). J.C. Penney puts Martha
Stewart plan on hold. Dallas Business
Journal. Retrieved from
http://www.bizjournals.com/dallas/news/2013/03/08/jc-penney-puts-martha-stewart-plan.html
Strand, R. (2008, Fall). The stakeholder dashboard. Greener Management International, (54),
23-36. Retrieved from
http://www.greenleaf-publishing.com/default.asp?ContentID=8
